Seller Price Expectations vs Market Reality

The Number in Your Head vs the Number on the Market

October 29, 2026•4 min read

Every owner has a number. Most have never said it out loud to anyone except a spouse, and some have not even done that.

The number is not the problem. Having one is normal and healthy. The problem is going to market with a number you have never tested, because the market tests it for you, in public, in front of the buyers you most wanted.

So test it yourself first. The exercise takes a couple of hours and it is the cheapest thing you will do in the entire process.

Write it down, then write down where it came from

Start with the number. Then, underneath it, write the honest source. Not the justification you would give a buyer, but the actual origin.

Common answers: a multiple someone mentioned at a supply house counter, what a competitor supposedly got two years ago, what your financial advisor says you need to retire at sixty-two, or a number you picked in 2019 and have been indexing upward ever since.

Seeing the source written next to the number does most of the work. If the origin has nothing to do with your company's earnings and transferability, you are holding a wish, and a wish will not survive first contact with a lender.

Ask what evidence would change your mind

This is the real pressure test, and it comes from a simple question: what would I have to see to move off this number?

If you cannot answer, the number is not a position. It is an attachment. An attachment cannot be negotiated with, including by you, and that is how owners end up turning down offers that were actually good.

Write three specific conditions. For example: "If two independent recastings of my earnings land materially below what I assumed, if a lender tells me the cash flow will not carry debt on that price, or if three qualified buyers pass for the same stated reason, I will revise." Committing to those conditions while you are calm is worth more than any amount of resolve later.

What a real opinion of value involves

An opinion of value worth having is not a multiple applied to a revenue figure. It starts with recast financials, meaning three years of earnings normalized with defensible add-backs and a market-rate replacement for the work you personally do.

It considers comparable transaction data rather than stories. It accounts for the things that move the multiple: customer concentration, recurring revenue, margin trend, team depth, and how much of the business depends on you. It gets tested against what a lender will actually finance at that price. And it produces a range with a structure attached, not a single number floating free.

That last point matters. Four million with half of it contingent on performance after you leave is a very different outcome than three and a half million with a clean close, even though the headline says otherwise. Tax treatment differs across deal structures too, so run any structure past your own CPA and attorney. This is not legal or tax advice.

What to do when the answer comes back lower

It often does. You have three legitimate options and only three.

Go anyway, because the life you want on the other side is worth more than the gap. Wait and fix, spending eighteen to thirty-six months moving the specific things that suppress your multiple, which is a real strategy with a real payoff when the gaps are fixable. Or test the market carefully with clear eyes, accepting that you may confirm the appraisal.

What is not an option is going to market at your number, watching it sit, and calling the market wrong. That path costs you time, momentum, and the buyers who looked first.

And if it comes back higher

It happens more than owners expect, usually when a company has quietly built recurring revenue or a defensible position without ever putting a value on it.

The right response is not to celebrate and slow down. It is to ask what is producing the premium and whether it is durable, because anything that lifted the number can also fall away. A concentration of commercial contracts is worth a lot right up until one of them does not renew.

Either way, you now have a number you can defend and a set of conditions that would change it. That is the difference between negotiating and hoping, and it is the frame we will carry into the next stretch of posts.

If you have a number in your head and no evidence behind it yet, book a strategy session and we will pressure-test it together before the market does.

Book a strategy session

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript


Coach Tim Moses

Coach Tim Moses

Master Business, Sales Coach & Dream Builder. Over thirty years as entrepreneur and business leadership, including Fortune 100 roles, with executive education from Harvard, Notre Dame, and Wharton. Certified ValueBuilder advisor. I help owners turn businesses that run them, into businesses that are worth buying.

Back to Blog